Can you stop someone from contesting a will

wills

You generally cannot stop an eligible person from contesting a will in NSW, and a will cannot exclude a family provision claim. You can reduce the risk through careful drafting, a testamentary statement of reasons, and proper execution. A Court-approved release under Section 95 is the only way to prevent a claim.

On this page

Introduction

Clients planning their estates often ask me whether they can stop someone from contesting a will. Executors and beneficiaries ask the same question after a death, usually when a family member has started making threats. The honest answer is that you cannot stop an eligible person from bringing a claim. You can, however, make a claim much harder to bring and much less likely to succeed.

This guide explains what the law allows, what it does not, and the practical steps will-makers and executors can take to protect an estate.

Go to top

What the law allows

Generally, no. There are two ways to contest a will in NSW, and the law protects both.

The first is a challenge to the will’s validity. A person with a legitimate interest can argue that the will-maker lacked capacity, was subject to undue influence, or did not properly execute the will. The Supreme Court lists these grounds on its contested proceedings page. The strongest defence against a validity challenge is a will made properly in the first place.

The second is a family provision claim under Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006. An eligible person, such as a spouse, child, or former spouse, can ask the Court to order provision from the estate. This right comes from statute, which means a will-maker cannot simply write it away.

What you can do is reduce the risk of a claim, weaken a claim that has no merit, and put the estate in the best position to resolve a dispute quickly. Our guide on the grounds to contest a will in NSW explains both types of claim in more detail.

Go to top

Why a will cannot block a claim

No. A will cannot remove an eligible person’s right to apply for a family provision order. A clause stating that a child “shall not make any claim against my estate” does not bind the Court.

The purpose of family provision law is to ensure adequate provision is made for eligible persons, whether or not there is a will and whether or not the eligible person was mentioned in it. The State Library of NSW’s guide to contesting a will describes that purpose. A will-maker who wants to reduce the risk of a claim needs to rely on other tools, which we set out below.

Go to top

Using a no-contest clause

A no-contest clause makes a gift conditional on the beneficiary not challenging the will. For example, a will might leave a child $100,000 on the condition that they do not contest the will, with the gift passing elsewhere if they do.

These clauses have limited effect in NSW. They cannot prevent the Court from making a family provision order, because that power comes from the Succession Act 2006 and cannot be excluded by the will. A clause that tries to punish a beneficiary for seeking the Court’s protection may also be treated as contrary to public policy.

A no-contest clause can still have some practical value. A beneficiary who would receive a reasonable gift may think carefully before risking it, particularly if their claim is weak. But the clause will not stop a determined claimant with a genuine case, and it should never be the only line of defence.

Go to top

How to reduce the risk

Most will disputes are avoidable, or at least manageable, with the right planning. In my experience, the steps that make the biggest difference are:

  • Consider every eligible person. Think about everyone who could make a family provision claim, including former spouses, children from earlier relationships, and anyone financially dependent on you.
  • Make adequate provision where it is warranted. A modest gift to a child you would otherwise exclude can reduce the risk of a larger claim.
  • Record your reasons. A clear written explanation of why someone received less, or nothing, can be persuasive evidence.
  • Keep your will up to date. Marriage generally revokes an earlier will under Section 12 of the Succession Act 2006, and divorce generally revokes gifts to a former spouse under Section 13.
  • Understand what sits outside your will. Jointly held property and superannuation can still be drawn into a claim as notional estate under Part 3.3 of the Succession Act 2006.
  • Use a lawyer. A professionally drafted will, with proper file notes, is far harder to challenge than a homemade one.

Our wills team prepares wills with these risks in mind.

Go to top

Explain your reasons in writing

Yes, and it is one of the most useful steps a will-maker can take. A testamentary statement is a signed and dated document, kept with the will, that explains the reasons for the will-maker’s decisions. It might set out

  • why a child was excluded,
  • what support they already received during the will-maker’s lifetime, or
  • why another person was preferred.

When the Court decides a family provision claim, Section 60(2) of the Succession Act 2006 lets it consider a wide range of matters. These include

  • the relationship between the applicant and the deceased,
  • any provision the deceased made for them during their lifetime,
  • the applicant’s character and conduct, and
  • evidence of the deceased’s testamentary intentions.

A well-prepared statement puts the will-maker’s own account before the Court.

A statement does not guarantee the outcome. The Court looks at circumstances at the date of the hearing, and it applies community standards. A child in genuine financial need may still receive provision despite a clear statement of reasons. The statement also needs to be accurate and measured, because an exaggerated or bitter account can undermine it.

Go to top

Follow proper will-making steps

Proper procedure is the best protection against a validity challenge. The Supreme Court recognises lack of capacity, lack of knowledge and approval, undue influence, and improper execution as grounds for challenge. Each is harder to establish where the will was made carefully.

The steps that help most are:

  • Proper execution. Section 6 of the Succession Act 2006 requires the will to be signed by the will-maker in the presence of two witnesses present at the same time.
  • Independent witnesses. Under Section 10 of the Succession Act 2006, a gift to a beneficiary who witnessed the will can be void unless certain conditions are met.
  • Detailed file notes. The solicitor should record the instructions, the will-maker’s reasons, and their apparent understanding.
  • Capacity evidence. Where capacity may be questioned, a medical assessment close to the date of signing can be decisive.
  • No beneficiary in the room. Instructions should come from the will-maker alone, which answers any later suggestion of pressure.
  • Safe storage. The original will can be deposited with the Supreme Court of NSW or held by the solicitor, so it cannot be lost or destroyed.

Go to top

Get a release before death

In one way, yes. Section 95 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) allows a person to release their right to make a family provision claim, but only if the Court approves the release. The State Library of NSW notes this often happens as part of a property settlement after divorce.

The Court will not approve a release lightly. It will generally want to be satisfied that the release is to the advantage of the person giving it, that it is prudent and fair, and that they have received independent legal advice. A release without Court approval has no effect.

Because Buckley Lawyers is a family law practice, we often see the value of dealing with estate claims at the same time as a property settlement. A financial agreement or settlement that includes an approved release can give both parties certainty about their estates.

Other lifetime strategies are less reliable. Moving assets out of your name before death may not protect them. Under Part 3.3 of the Succession Act 2006, the Court can designate property as notional estate if it was transferred within three years of death with the intention of denying an eligible person provision. It can also designate property transferred within one year of death, where the deceased had a moral obligation to provide for the eligible person. Transactions that take effect on death, such as joint tenancy survivorship, can also be caught.

Go to top

What executors can do

Executors are in a difficult position. They must uphold the will while protecting the estate from unnecessary costs. When someone threatens a claim, an executor should:

  • Get legal advice early. An executor’s reasonable costs of defending a claim are usually paid from the estate.
  • Hold off on distribution. Section 93 of the Succession Act 2006 protects an executor who distributes after six months, but only if they have no notice of a claim. Once a claim is threatened, distributing can expose the executor personally.
  • Stay neutral. The executor’s role is to put the evidence before the Court, not to fight for one beneficiary over another.
  • Provide the will where required. Section 54 of the Succession Act 2006 entitles certain people to inspect and obtain a copy of the will.
  • Challenge baseless caveats. If someone without a legitimate interest files a caveat, the executor can apply to have it removed under Part 78 Rule 71 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970.
  • Engage in mediation. Section 98 of the Succession Act 2006 requires mediation before a family provision hearing, and most claims settle there.

A formal offer of compromise can also shift the costs risk onto a claimant who unreasonably refuses to settle. Our guides on how long a claimant has to contest a will and how much it costs to contest a will in NSW explain the timing and costs issues executors need to understand.

Go to top

Protect the estate

You cannot stop every claim, but you can make sure that any claim faces a well-drafted will, clear reasons, and strong evidence. For will-makers, that work starts now. For executors, it starts the moment a dispute is threatened.

Buckley Lawyers helps clients plan their estates to reduce the risk of disputes and acts for executors and beneficiaries when claims are made. We focus on resolving disputes efficiently through negotiation and mediation, and on protecting the estate from costs. See our contested estates page for more.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Go to top

Articles
Have a problem?
Call 02 9220 1737 or
Fill the form
Google Rating
4.7
Based on 64 reviews
×
js_loader
Google Rating
4.7
Based on 64 reviews
×
js_loader