Are Binding Financial Agreements Enforceable?

financial agreements

Yes. A binding financial agreement is enforceable in Australia if it meets the formal requirements of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), including independent legal advice for both parties. A court can set it aside only on specific grounds, such as fraud, non-disclosure, duress, or unconscionable conduct. Agreements generally survive death.

On this page

Introduction

Many couples hesitate over a binding financial agreement because they have heard that “prenups never hold up in court”. That is not accurate. A properly prepared BFA is a legally enforceable contract, and courts regularly uphold them. The agreements that fail usually fail for identifiable reasons, most of which can be avoided with the right process at the start.

This guide answers the question of whether binding financial agreements are enforceable in Australia. It explains what makes an agreement binding, the grounds on which a court can set one aside, and how agreements operate after separation and after death.

Go to top

Enforceability

Yes. Legal Aid NSW confirms that a valid binding financial agreement is legally enforceable. It also stops a court from hearing a dispute and making orders about the property or maintenance issues the agreement covers.

The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia describes the effect in similar terms. A binding agreement ousts the Court’s jurisdiction over financial or property proceedings between the parties, either generally or on specific issues. In other words, a properly made agreement lets a couple contract out of court proceedings about their property.

Enforceability depends on two things. The agreement must meet the requirements of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), and it must not fall within one of the grounds on which the Court can set it aside. Each is explained below.

Go to top

What makes a BFA binding

The requirements are set out in Section 90G of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) for married couples, and Section 90UJ for de facto couples. Legal Aid NSW summarises them. To be legally valid, a binding financial agreement must:

  • Be in writing
  • State which part of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) it is made under
  • Deal with property, financial resources, spousal maintenance, or related matters
  • Be signed by all parties
  • Be made after each party has received independent legal advice
  • Include a separation declaration, where one is required
  • Not deal with matters already covered by an earlier agreement that is still in force
  • Not have been terminated or set aside by a court

The agreement must also be made under the correct provision. A married couple can make an agreement before the marriage under Section 90B, during it under Section 90C, or after divorce under Section 90D. De facto couples use Sections 90UB, 90UC, and 90UD.

Go to top

Because the agreement cannot be binding without it. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia states that each party must be given independent legal advice by an Australian legal practitioner about prescribed matters before entering into the agreement. Under Section 90G, that advice must cover the effect of the agreement on the party’s rights, and its advantages and disadvantages. Each lawyer must provide a signed statement confirming the advice was given.

The requirement protects both parties. It means each person signs knowing what they are giving up. It also makes the agreement harder to attack later, because a party who received clear, independent advice will struggle to argue they did not understand what they were signing.

One lawyer cannot advise both parties. Each party needs their own lawyer, acting only in that party’s interests. Our guide on how much a binding financial agreement costs explains what that advice involves.

Go to top

Setting aside a BFA

Yes, but only on specific grounds. The Court’s power to set aside an agreement is in Section 90K of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) for married couples, and Section 90UM for de facto couples. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia confirms the Court has that power “in some circumstances”, and that anyone who thinks an agreement should be set aside should get legal advice.

The grounds are limited. A party cannot have an agreement set aside simply because it has turned out to be a bad bargain, or because they have changed their mind. The Court needs one of the statutory grounds to be established.

Go to top

Grounds for setting aside

Legal Aid NSW lists the circumstances in which a court can set aside a binding financial agreement or a termination agreement. They include where:

  • One party committed fraud to obtain the agreement, such as hiding important financial information
  • One party made the agreement to avoid paying money owed to a creditor
  • One party made the agreement to defraud a person in a de facto relationship with one of the parties
  • The agreement is void, voidable, or unenforceable
  • It is no longer practicable to carry out all or part of the agreement
  • There has been a material change in circumstances relating to a child, and a party or the child would suffer hardship if the agreement stayed in place
  • One party acted unconscionably
  • There is a payment flag on one party’s superannuation, or the agreement deals with a superannuation interest that cannot be split

Go to top

Pressure and duress

Yes. An agreement signed under pressure can be set aside if it was obtained by undue influence or unconscionable conduct. Those grounds fall within Section 90K, because they can make an agreement voidable or unenforceable, and unconscionable conduct is listed as a separate ground.

The leading case is Thorne v Kennedy [2017] HCA 49. The High Court of Australia set aside a pre-nuptial agreement signed days before the wedding. The wife had moved to Australia to marry, had no substantial assets of her own, and was told the wedding would not proceed unless she signed. Her independent lawyer had advised her strongly against signing. The Court found the agreement was obtained by undue influence and unconscionable conduct.

The case shows that independent legal advice does not guarantee enforceability on its own. The circumstances in which an agreement is signed also matter. The lessons are clear:

  • Start the process well before a wedding or other deadline.
  • Give the other party time to consider the agreement and negotiate its terms.
  • Avoid tying the agreement to an ultimatum.
  • Make sure the terms are not so one-sided that they invite a challenge.

Go to top

Non-disclosure

Yes. Legal Aid NSW lists fraud, including hiding important financial information, as a ground for setting aside an agreement. Section 90K of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) extends fraud to include non-disclosure of a material matter.

This is one of the most common grounds for challenge. A party who conceals a business interest, an inheritance, a trust, or significant debt when the agreement is made gives the other party grounds to seek to have it set aside later.

Full and frank disclosure is therefore the best protection an agreement can have. Each party should set out their assets, liabilities, income, and financial resources, supported by documents such as tax returns and statements. Recording that disclosure in the agreement makes it much harder for either party to argue later that something was hidden.

Go to top

When requirements are not met

If an agreement fails to meet the requirements of Section 90G or 90UJ, it is not binding. The Court’s jurisdiction is no longer excluded, and either party can apply for property orders in the ordinary way under Section 79 or Section 90SM of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). The Court would then divide the property on its own assessment, regardless of what the parties agreed.

The Act gives the Court limited power to treat an agreement as binding despite a technical defect, if it would be unjust and inequitable not to. That power is found in Section 90G(1A) for married couples, and Section 90UJ(1A) for de facto couples. It is a safety net, not a substitute for getting the agreement right. A party relying on it faces the cost and uncertainty of court proceedings.

Go to top

Enforcing after separation

Yes. Separation is when most agreements are put to work. Once the parties separate, the agreement governs how the property and financial matters it covers are dealt with, and the Court cannot make orders on those matters.

Where an agreement made before or during a relationship is to take effect on separation, the relevant parts usually cannot operate until a separation declaration is made. Legal Aid NSW notes that a separation declaration must be included where necessary.

If one party does not comply with the agreement, the other can apply to the Court. The Court’s power to deal with the validity, enforceability, and effect of a financial agreement is in Section 90KA of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) for married couples, and Section 90UN for de facto couples. Our guide on binding financial agreements vs consent orders compares how each is enforced.

Go to top

Enforcing after death

Generally, yes. Legal Aid NSW notes that a binding financial agreement stays in force even if one of the parties dies, unless the agreement says otherwise. Section 90H of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) provides that an agreement continues to operate despite the death of a party, and is binding on and enforceable by the legal personal representative of the deceased party. The de facto equivalent is Section 90UK.

A BFA does not, however, automatically prevent a family provision claim against a deceased estate in NSW. A former spouse can be an eligible person under Section 57 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW). To exclude that claim, the party must release their family provision rights with the Supreme Court’s approval under Section 95 of that Act. Our guide on whether you can stop someone from contesting a will explains how releases work.

Anyone with a BFA should also review their will, so the two documents work together.

Go to top

Build an agreement that holds

Binding financial agreements are enforceable when they are made properly. The agreements that fail usually share the same problems: they were rushed, one party did not disclose everything, the terms were heavily one-sided, or the formal requirements were not met.

Buckley Lawyers prepares binding financial agreements designed to withstand scrutiny, and reviews existing agreements for defects. We also act for clients seeking to enforce an agreement, or to challenge one that should not stand. Visit our financial agreements page, or see our property settlements page if your agreement is being disputed after separation.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Go to top

Articles
Have a problem?
Call 02 9220 1737 or
Fill the form
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader