How Much Does It Cost to Contest a Will in NSW?

Buckley Lawyers Team

There is no fixed cost to contest a will in NSW. Legal fees drive the total, and court fees range from $57 for a caveat to $2,879 to allocate a hearing. In family provision claims, costs are often paid from the estate. Unsuccessful parties risk paying the other side’s costs.

On this page

Introduction

Before anyone contests a will, they want to know two things: how much it will cost, and who will end up paying. Those are the right questions to ask. A will dispute can be worth pursuing or defending, but only if the likely outcome justifies the expense.

This guide explains what drives the cost of contesting a will in NSW, which court fees apply, and how the Supreme Court decides who pays for contesting a will in NSW. It also covers what happens to costs when a dispute settles, which is how most of them end.

Go to top

What drives the cost

There is no fixed price, because no two disputes follow the same path. The total depends on three things:

  1. the type of claim,
  2. how far the dispute runs before it resolves, and
  3. how the parties behave along the way.

A claim that settles at an early mediation costs a fraction of one that runs to a final hearing with expert evidence.

It helps to understand that “contesting a will” covers two different types of claims, and the costs rules differ between them:

  • A challenge to the validity of the will. This argues the will should not be admitted to probate, for example because the will-maker lacked capacity, or the will was forged or made under undue influence. The Supreme Court lists the recognised grounds on its contested proceedings page.
  • A family provision claim. This accepts the will is valid but argues it fails to make adequate provision for an eligible person. These claims are made under Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006 and must be filed within 12 months of the date of death.

Most disputes I see are family provision claims. The Supreme Court is clear that a will cannot be set aside simply because someone believes they were not adequately provided for. That claim has its own process and its own costs rules.

Go to top

Legal fees make up most of the cost of any will dispute. They usually cover:

  • The initial advice on whether you have a claim and what it is worth
  • Gathering evidence, including financial records, medical records, and witness statements
  • Preparing affidavits and the court documents
  • The disclosure the Court requires from each party
  • Attending directions hearings and a mediation
  • A barrister’s fees if the matter proceeds to hearing
  • Expert reports, such as a medical opinion on capacity or a valuation of estate assets

Your lawyer must disclose the basis of their costs and give you an estimate at the outset, as required by Section 174 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law. Those costs must also be fair and reasonable under Section 172 of that Law. Ask for the estimate in stages, so you can see what the matter will cost to reach mediation and what it would cost to go further.

Some law practices offer conditional costs agreements, where fees are payable only on a successful outcome. Section 181 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law permits these agreements, and Section 182 caps any uplift fee at 25 per cent of the legal costs. Section 183 prohibits contingency fees calculated as a percentage of the amount recovered.

Go to top

Court fees

Court fees are small compared with legal fees, but they add up in a contested matter. Under the Supreme Court’s fee schedule from 1 July 2026, the key fees for an individual include:

Step Fee
Lodging a caveat to stop a grant of probate $57
Filing a summons or statement of claim to contest a probate matter $1,443
Allocating a hearing date $2,879
Each hearing day from day 2 to day 4 $1,148
Each hearing day from day 5 onwards $1,844

The Supreme Court warns that contested probate and family provision proceedings may attract daily hearing fees. A caveat lasts six months under Part 78 Division 69 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970, and it stops the Court issuing a grant while the dispute is sorted out.

Go to top

Who pays

Each party pays their own lawyer as the matter progresses. At the end, the Court decides who bears the costs, and the answer depends on the type of claim.

Family provision claims

Section 99 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) gives the Court power to order that costs be paid out of the estate or notional estate, in the manner it thinks fit. As the State Library of NSW’s guide to contesting a will explains, the costs of a successful application are generally paid from the estate. The executor’s reasonable costs of defending the claim are also usually paid from the estate.

Go to top

Validity challenges

Probate disputes are closer to ordinary litigation. Under Section 98 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005, the Court has a broad discretion over costs. Rule 42.1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 sets the general position that costs follow the event, which means the unsuccessful party usually pays.

The Supreme Court states plainly that unsuccessful applicants in both types of proceeding may be ordered to pay the costs of the successful party. That risk is real, and it is the single most important factor in deciding whether to bring a claim.

Go to top

Recovering your costs

Often, but rarely in full. A costs order covers costs on the ordinary basis, which means reasonable costs properly incurred in the proceedings. The gap between what you pay your lawyer and what the Court orders the other side or the estate to pay can be considerable.

In family provision matters, Section 99(2) of the Succession Act 2006 allows regulations to fix the maximum costs that can be paid out of the estate. The Court also looks closely at whether the costs were proportionate to what was at stake.

Offers matter too. A party who makes a reasonable formal offer of compromise, which the other side rejects and then fails to beat at hearing, can be entitled to a more favourable costs order. Offers of compromise are governed by Part 20 Division 4 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005. A well-timed offer is one of the most effective tools for protecting yourself against costs.

Go to top

Costs when a dispute settles

Most will disputes settle, and the settlement terms deal with costs. Common outcomes include:

  • Each party’s costs are paid from the estate before it is distributed.
  • The claimant receives a lump sum inclusive of their costs.
  • Each party bears their own costs.

Mediation is where most of these agreements are reached. Section 98 of the Succession Act 2006 requires family provision proceedings to be mediated before a hearing, unless there are special reasons, such as a risk of violence. Practice Note SC Eq 7 also requires parties to prepare a disclosure statement, which gives everyone a clearer picture of the estate early on.

Settling at mediation avoids the hearing allocation fee, daily hearing fees, and the largest block of legal fees. Our mediation services are built on that principle: resolve the dispute before the costs consume the estate.

Go to top

Estate size and costs

The size of the estate affects both the stakes and the Court’s approach to costs. In a family provision claim, the Court considers the size of the estate when deciding what provision to make. Costs that are out of proportion to the estate are unlikely to be allowed in full.

The Supreme Court also applies a costs capping protocol in probate proceedings. Parties must tell the Court in writing if the net value of the estate is less than $1.5 million. That rule is designed to stop legal costs from swallowing a modest estate.

In a large estate, the dispute can justify more investment in evidence and expert reports. The Court still expects the parties to act proportionately, and a party who runs up unnecessary costs risks having them disallowed.

Go to top

What drives costs up

In my experience, these are the factors that most often drive costs up:

  • Delay. Claims filed after the 12-month limit need an application for an extension of time, which adds a contested step before the claim is even heard.
  • Multiple claimants. Each additional party adds evidence, correspondence, and hearing time.
  • Contested evidence of capacity. Validity challenges often require medical records and expert opinion, which are costly to obtain and test.
  • Notional estate claims. Where assets have passed outside the estate, such as jointly held property, the Court may need to consider designating them as notional estate under Part 3.3 of the Succession Act 2006. That adds complexity and cost.
  • Refusing to negotiate. A party who will not engage in mediation, or rejects a reasonable offer, can end up paying far more than the dispute was worth.

The cheapest dispute is one that is assessed properly at the start. Understanding what a claim is realistically worth, and what it will cost to get there, is the first thing we do in any contested estate matter.

Go to top

Get a clear view of the costs

Contesting or defending a will is a financial decision as much as a legal one. You need a realistic estimate of what the claim is worth, what it will cost to pursue, and what you risk if it fails. That assessment should happen before any document is filed.

Buckley Lawyers acts for claimants, beneficiaries, and executors in will disputes across Sydney. We are outcome-focused and cost-conscious, and we look for resolution before escalation. To learn more, read our guide on what a contested estate is and when a will can be challenged, or see our contested estates page.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Go to top

 

Articles
Have a problem?
Call 02 9220 1737 or
Fill the form
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader