A contested estate is any deceased estate where someone disputes how it should be dealt with. In NSW, that covers will validity challenges, family provision claims, probate caveats, and disputes over administration. Each has different rules, deadlines, and costs, and the Supreme Court manages them in its Probate and Family Provision List.
Estate disputes come with their own vocabulary, and the terms are often used loosely. A person might say they want to “contest a will” when they really mean a family provision claim, or talk about “challenging probate” when the grant has not yet been made. Those differences matter, because each term refers to a different legal process with its own rules, deadlines, and costs. This glossary explains the key terms in simple words.
A contested estate is a deceased estate where someone disputes how it should be dealt with. The dispute might concern
In NSW, the Supreme Court manages contested estate matters in its Probate and Family Provision List. The term is not a formal legal category but a label that covers several distinct types of proceeding, which the definitions below explain.
People also search for the meaning of “contested property”. In an estate, contested property is any asset that is the subject of competing claims. That can include property in the estate itself, and property outside the estate that the Court designates as notional estate under Part 3.3 of the Succession Act 2006, such as jointly held assets or distributed property.
The phrase has a separate meaning in family law. A contested property settlement is a dispute between separating spouses or de facto partners about dividing their property, under Section 79 or Section 90SM of the Family Law Act 1975. The two areas can overlap. Under Section 79(8) of that Act, property proceedings that have already started can continue after one party dies, with the deceased party’s legal personal representative taking their place. Our property settlements page explains the family law side.
Contesting a will is an umbrella term for disputing the effect of a will. In NSW, it usually refers to one of two things:
In everyday use, the meaning of a contested will covers both. Most people who say they want to contest a will are unhappy with what they received, and that concern is addressed by a family provision claim. The Supreme Court states on its contested proceedings page that a will cannot be set aside simply because someone claims they were not adequately provided for.
A will challenge is a dispute about whether a document should be accepted as the deceased’s valid last will. It is heard in the Court’s probate jurisdiction.
The person challenging the will must have a legitimate interest in which will is admitted to probate. An executor or beneficiary under a different will is the typical example. The Supreme Court notes that family provision claimants and creditors are not interested persons for this purpose, because their claims do not depend on which will is proved.
Our guide on the grounds to contest a will in NSW explains what a will challenge requires.
A family provision claim is an application to the Supreme Court of NSW for a share, or a larger share, of a deceased estate. It is made under Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006, and it applies whether or not there is a will.
Only an eligible person can make the claim. Section 57 of the Succession Act 2006 lists them, and they include a spouse or de facto partner, a child, a former spouse, certain dependants, and a person in a close personal relationship with the deceased. Legal Aid NSW explains who qualifies and what the Court considers.
The claim must be filed within 12 months of the date of death under Section 58(2) of the Succession Act 2006, unless the Court extends the time. Section 98 requires mediation before a hearing. Our guide on how long you have to contest a will in NSW covers the deadline in detail.
A probate caveat is a document filed with the Supreme Court that stops the Court from making a grant of probate or administration. It remains in force for six months from the date it is filed, under Part 78 Division 10 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970.
A caveat can only be filed by a person with a legitimate interest in the probate proceedings. It must be served on any known applicant or potential applicant for a grant.
A caveat buys time while a validity dispute is investigated. It does not resolve the dispute. If the applicant for probate believes the caveator has no legitimate interest, they can apply to have the caveat removed under Part 78 Rule 71 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970.
Challenging the validity of a will means arguing that the document is not legally effective as the deceased’s will. The Supreme Court recognises these circumstances as grounds for a challenge:
If the challenge succeeds, the will is not admitted to probate. The estate then passes under an earlier valid will or, if there is none, under the intestacy rules in Chapter 4 of the Succession Act 2006. Our guide on your chances of successfully contesting a will explains what makes these challenges succeed or fail.
A grant of probate is an order of the Supreme Court confirming that a will is valid and that the executor has authority to administer the estate. The Supreme Court explains that the grant is based on the understanding that the will is valid and represents the deceased’s last testamentary intentions.
In a contested estate, the grant is where the dispute often begins. A caveat can stop a grant being made. If the grant has already been made, a person with a legitimate interest can ask the Court to revoke it. The Supreme Court confirms that revoking the grant is the only way to remove an executor once probate has been granted.
A family provision claim works differently. It can be made before or after probate, because it does not challenge the grant itself. Our complete guide to grant of probate in NSW explains the grant in detail, and our guide on contesting a will after probate covers disputes that arise later.
Probate in solemn form is a grant made by a judge after contested proceedings in which the validity of the will has been decided. It contrasts with a grant in common form, which a Registrar makes on the papers when no one disputes the application.
Proceedings for probate in solemn form are commenced by statement of claim under Part 78 Rule 72 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970. A notice of proceedings, with the statement of claim and any will propounded, must be served on everyone who would be adversely affected by the grant, under Part 78 Rules 57 and 64.
Because interested persons are given notice and the chance to be heard, a grant in solemn form carries greater finality than a grant in common form.
A contested estate proceeding is any court case in which the parties dispute the will or the estate. In the Supreme Court of NSW, all contested proceedings are managed in the Probate and Family Provision List.
Matters filed on or after 17 July 2024 must comply with Practice Note SC Eq 7. The Court will generally require the parties to prepare a disclosure statement setting out key information about the estate and the claims.
A contested estate proceeding can arise in two ways. A person served with notice of a probate application can file an appearance and be joined as a defendant. Alternatively, a person can commence proceedings directly, by statement of claim in a probate dispute or by summons in a family provision claim. The Supreme Court warns that these proceedings can be complex and attract daily hearing fees. Our guide on how much it costs to contest a will in NSW explains the fees and costs rules.
A will dispute concerns the will itself. It asks whether the will is valid, what it means, or whether it should be corrected. An estate dispute is broader. It covers any disagreement about the estate, whether or not the will is in question.
| Will Disputes | Estate Disputes |
|---|---|
| Challenges to the will’s validity | Family provision claims |
| Applications to construe an unclear will | Disputes about how the executor is administering the estate |
| Applications to rectify a will under Section 27 of the Succession Act 2006 | Applications for executors’ accounts under Section 85(2) of the Probate and Administration Act 1898 |
| Disputes about which of two wills is the last | Claims to notional estate under Part 3.3 of the Succession Act 2006 |
The State Library of NSW’s guide to contesting a will explains the Court’s powers to interpret and rectify wills. Every will dispute is an estate dispute, but many estate disputes involve a will that nobody says is invalid.
The terminology is not academic. The claim you choose decides the deadline you must meet, who can bring it, how costs are treated, and what the Court can order. Picking the wrong one can cost months and leave a genuine claim out of time.
Buckley Lawyers advises claimants, beneficiaries, and executors across the full range of contested estate matters. We identify the right claim at the outset and pursue resolution through negotiation and mediation wherever possible. Read our guide on what a contested estate is and when a will can be challenged, or visit our contested estates page.
Contact us today to schedule a consultation.