Yes, you can contest a will after probate in NSW. A validity challenge asks the Court to revoke the grant, while a family provision claim must still be filed within 12 months of death. Distributed assets can sometimes be recovered as notional estate. Executors on notice of a claim should not distribute.
Many people only learn about a problem with a will after probate has been granted. A later will turns up, a family member raises concerns about the will-maker’s capacity, or someone realises they were left out altogether. The question then becomes whether it is too late to act.
It usually is not. You can contest a will after probate, but the grant changes the process, and delay makes every option harder. This guide explains what happens if probate is contested, which claims remain open, and what executors must do once a dispute arises.
If you need background on the grant itself first, our complete guide to grant of probate in NSW explains what probate is, what it does, and how the process works.
Yes. A grant of probate does not make a will immune from challenge. The Supreme Court states on its contested proceedings page that it is preferable to challenge a will before probate is granted and before the executor has dealt with the estate’s assets. That is a preference, and challenges can still be brought after the grant in appropriate circumstances.
What changes after the grant is the route. Before probate, a person with a legitimate interest can lodge a caveat to stop the grant being made. After probate, the caveat is no longer available, and the challenge must instead ask the Court to revoke the grant.
The two main types of claim work differently after probate:
The first step is to identify what kind of problem it is. The most common situations are:
Each problem has a different remedy and a different deadline. Getting advice quickly matters, because the executor may be distributing the estate while you work out what to do.
Yes. Most uncontested grants are made by a Registrar on the papers, in what is known as common form. A grant in common form can be revoked if it later emerges that it should not have been made.
The Supreme Court confirms that the only way to remove an executor after probate has been granted is an order revoking the grant. If the validity of the will is in dispute, the matter proceeds as a claim for probate in solemn form under Part 78 Rule 72 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970. Those proceedings are commenced by statement of claim and decided by a judge. Notice must be served on everyone who would be adversely affected, under Part 78 Rules 57 and 64.
Revocation protects people who acted in good faith on the original grant. Section 90 of the Probate and Administration Act 1898 keeps payments made under a revoked grant valid. Section 91 protects people who made payments to an executor on the strength of a grant. The executor must account for the estate, but banks and other asset holders are generally not required to pay twice.
Yes. The recognised grounds are the same before and after the grant. The Supreme Court lists them as:
A challenge after probate faces practical hurdles. The estate may already be partly distributed, evidence may be harder to gather, and the Court will want to know why the challenge was not made earlier. You also need a legitimate interest in which will is admitted, such as being a beneficiary under an earlier will.
Our guides on the grounds to contest a will in NSW and your chances of successfully contesting a will explain each ground and the evidence it requires.
Yes, and this is the most common claim made after probate. A family provision claim does not depend on whether probate has been granted. Legal Aid NSW confirms that it is not necessary to obtain a grant before making the claim, and the same claim can be made after the grant.
The deadline is the key issue. A family provision claim must be filed within 12 months of the date of death under Section 58(2) of the Succession Act 2006, unless the Court extends the time. The deadline runs from the death, not from the date of the grant. By the time probate has been granted, a good part of that period has often passed.
The claim is filed by summons and affidavit in the Equity Division of the Supreme Court, against the executor. Section 98 of the Succession Act 2006 requires mediation before a hearing. Our guide on how long you have to contest a will in NSW explains the deadline and when the Court will extend it.
Distribution makes a claim harder, but it does not always end it.
For family provision claims, Part 3.3 of the Succession Act 2006 allows the Court to designate property as notional estate. That includes property that has already been distributed from the estate, where the transaction took effect on or after the death. The Court can then make a family provision order against that property. The State Library of NSW’s guide to contesting a will notes that these orders are made only in limited circumstances.
For validity challenges, distribution creates difficulty. If the grant is revoked, the executor must account for what they did with the estate. Recovering assets that have already been paid to beneficiaries can be complex and expensive.
The executor’s position also matters. Section 93 of the Succession Act 2006 protects an executor from personal liability to a family provision claimant if they distributed at least six months after the death. They must also have published a notice of intended distribution with a period of at least 30 days and had no notice of a claim. If those conditions were met, the claimant cannot pursue the executor personally, and notional estate may be the only avenue.
An executor who knows of a claim takes a serious risk by distributing. The Section 93 protection only applies where the executor has no notice of a claim at the time of distribution. Once a claimant has put the executor on notice, distributing the estate can expose the executor to personal liability.
For that reason, anyone considering a claim should notify the executor in writing as early as possible. The executor should then:
Beneficiaries who are concerned about how the executor is dealing with the estate have their own remedy. Section 85(2) of the Probate and Administration Act 1898 allows any interested person to apply for an order requiring the executor to produce and verify the estate accounts. Our guide on how beneficiaries receive their money after probate explains the distribution process from the beneficiary’s side.
Depending on the problem, the main options are:
| Problem | Legal Option |
|---|---|
| The will is invalid or a later will exists | Proceedings to revoke the grant and prove the correct will in solemn form |
| The will fails to provide adequately for an eligible person | A family provision claim under Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006 |
| The will contains a drafting error | An application for rectification under Section 27 of the Succession Act 2006 |
| The will’s meaning is unclear | An application to the Court to construe the will |
| The executor is not accounting properly | An order for the production of accounts under Section 85(2) of the Probate and Administration Act 1898 |
Most of these disputes can be resolved without a final hearing. Negotiation and mediation are usually faster and cheaper than litigation, and they protect the estate from costs. The Supreme Court warns that unsuccessful parties may be ordered to pay the costs of the successful party. Our guide on how much it costs to contest a will in NSW explains that risk.
A grant of probate is not the end of the road, but every week after it narrows your options. Assets are sold, distributions are made, and the 12-month family provision deadline keeps running.
Buckley Lawyers acts for claimants, beneficiaries, and executors in disputes that arise after probate. We identify the right claim, put the executor on notice, and pursue resolution before the estate is dispersed. See our grant of probate page for how we help executors, or our contested estates page for disputes.
Contact us today to schedule a consultation.