A grandchild can contest a will in NSW by making a family provision claim, but only if they were at some time wholly or partly dependent on the grandparent. Living together is not required. The Court must also find factors warranting the claim. Validity challenges are rarer and need a legitimate interest.
Grandchildren often assume they have no say in a grandparent’s estate, or that they can challenge any will that leaves them out. Neither is quite right. The answer to whether a grandchild can contest a will depends on what kind of claim they want to make and on their relationship with the grandparent during their lifetime.
There are two separate legal paths. One challenges whether the will is valid at all. The other accepts the will is valid but asks the Court to order provision from the estate. For grandchildren, the second path is far more common, and it comes with specific eligibility requirements.
Most grandchildren who contest a will do so by making a family provision claim under Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006. That claim asks the Supreme Court to order that the grandchild receive provision, or greater provision, from the estate.
Being a grandchild is not enough on its own. A grandchild must first qualify as an eligible person, which depends on whether they were dependent on the grandparent at some point. They must then persuade the Court that there are factors warranting the claim and that the will did not make adequate provision for them.
A grandchild can also challenge the validity of a will, but only where they have a legitimate interest in which will is admitted to probate. That is less common, and we explain it below.
Section 57 of the Succession Act 2006 sets out who is an eligible person. A grandchild falls within that section if they were, at any particular time, wholly or partly dependent on the deceased. Legal Aid NSW describes this category in the same terms in its guidance on family provision claims.
Three features of that requirement are worth understanding:
Whether a particular form of support amounts to dependence is a question of fact. Occasional gifts, birthday money, or help with childcare may not meet the threshold, while regular, meaningful support with living costs may.
No. The dependency category in Section 57 covers two groups:
For a grandchild, living together is not a requirement. What must be shown is that they were wholly or partly dependent on the grandparent at some point.
A grandchild who lived with a grandparent for years is often able to show dependence more easily, because the grandparent was likely providing housing, food, and day-to-day care. Shared living arrangements also tend to produce clear evidence of the relationship.
Grandchildren raised by a grandparent are among the strongest claimants in this category. In those cases, the grandparent often stood in the place of a parent, and the dependence is obvious.
Yes. The Act does not exclude a grandchild because one or both of their parents are alive. Eligibility turns on dependence on the grandparent alone.
A living parent can, however, affect how strong the claim is. When deciding what provision to order, the Court considers whether any other person is responsible for supporting the applicant. A grandchild whose parents are able to support them may find it harder to show that the grandparent’s estate should provide for them.
The Court also considers any provision the grandchild is likely to receive indirectly. If the will leaves a substantial gift to the grandchild’s parent, the Court may take into account that the parent can use it to support their child. This is one reason why grandchild claims turn so heavily on the family circumstances.
Yes, if they are an eligible person. Legal Aid NSW confirms that an eligible person can make a family provision claim if
The claim is also available where the grandparent died without a will, because family provision applies whether or not there is a will.
Being left nothing is not, however, a ground for having the will declared invalid. The Supreme Court states on its contested proceedings page that a will cannot be set aside simply because someone claims the will-maker failed to make adequate provision for them.
For grandchildren, there is an extra step. Section 59(1)(b) of the Succession Act 2006 requires the Court to be satisfied that there are factors warranting the application. That applies to eligible persons in the dependency category, including grandchildren. A grandchild who was left nothing must therefore show why the Court should entertain their claim at all, before it considers what provision to make.
A family provision claim must be filed within 12 months of the date of death under Section 58(2) of the Succession Act 2006. Our guide on how long you have to contest a will in NSW explains that deadline.
Section 60(2) of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) lists the matters the Court may consider. According to Legal Aid NSW, they include:
For a grandchild, the Court looks closely at
The deceased’s children are often also claimants or beneficiaries, and the Court must weigh the grandchild’s claim against theirs.
The Court assesses the circumstances as they stand at the date of the hearing. A grandchild’s needs for education, housing, or medical care at the time of hearing can therefore carry significant weight.
Sometimes. A validity challenge argues that the will should not be admitted to probate, for example because the grandparent lacked capacity, was subject to undue influence, or did not know and approve of its contents. The Supreme Court lists these grounds on its contested proceedings page.
To bring that challenge, a grandchild needs a legitimate interest in which will is admitted to probate. That usually arises in two situations:
A grandchild who would receive nothing more under an earlier will or intestacy gains nothing from a successful validity challenge. In that situation, a family provision claim is usually the only realistic option. Our guide on the grounds to contest a will in NSW explains validity challenges in more detail.
A family provision claim is started by filing a summons and supporting affidavit in the Equity Division of the Supreme Court. The Court also generally requires the parties to prepare a disclosure statement under Practice Note SC Eq 7. For a grandchild, the evidence usually needs to cover four areas:
If the grandchild is under 18, the claim is brought on their behalf, usually by a parent or guardian acting as their representative in the proceedings.
Most family provision claims are resolved without a hearing. Section 98 of the Succession Act 2006 requires mediation before a hearing, unless there are special reasons, such as a risk of violence. Costs of a successful claim are generally paid from the estate under Section 99, but unsuccessful claimants may be ordered to pay costs. Our guide on how much it costs to contest a will in NSW explains that risk.
Grandchild claims are more finely balanced than claims by a spouse or child. Eligibility depends on dependence, the Court must first be satisfied that there are factors warranting the claim, and the grandchild’s parents are often competing for the same estate. An honest assessment at the start saves time, cost, and family relationships.
Buckley Lawyers advises grandchildren, their parents, and executors on estate claims across Sydney. We work out whether a claim is available, gather the evidence of dependence, and pursue resolution through negotiation and mediation wherever possible. Read more about what a contested estate is and when a will can be challenged, or visit our contested estates page.
Contact us today to schedule a consultation.