Grounds to Contest a Will in NSW

Common Reasons a Will or Estate Is Contested

A will’s validity can be challenged in NSW for lack of capacity, lack of knowledge and approval, undue influence, forgery or fraud, improper execution, or revocation. Being left out is not a ground for invalidity. Eligible people can instead bring a family provision claim within 12 months of death.

On this page

Introduction

People often ask on what grounds a will can be contested in Australia. Each state has its own legislation, but the core grounds for challenging a will’s validity are similar across the country because they come largely from the same common law. This guide focuses on the grounds to contest a will in NSW, where the Supreme Court decides these disputes.

The most important distinction to understand early is this: challenging whether a will is valid and claiming a bigger share of an estate are two separate legal processes. Choosing the wrong one wastes time and money, and it can leave a genuine claim out of time.

Go to top

Grounds for a challenge

The Supreme Court of NSW identifies the circumstances in which a person may challenge the validity of a will. According to its contested proceedings page, those grounds are that:

  • The will is not the last will of the deceased.
  • The will-maker lacked testamentary capacity when the will was made.
  • The will-maker did not know and approve of the contents of the will.
  • The will is a forgery, was made under undue influence or pressure, or is fraudulent.
  • The will was not executed in accordance with Part 2.1 of the Succession Act 2006.
  • The will-maker revoked the will during their lifetime.

If one of these grounds is made out, the will may not be admitted to probate. The estate would then pass under an earlier valid will or, if there is none, under the intestacy rules. The Court prefers any challenge to be made before probate is granted and before the executor has dealt with the estate’s assets.

Go to top

Lack of capacity

Yes. Testamentary capacity is the mental ability required to make a valid will. The test still applied in NSW comes from Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549. In broad terms, the will-maker must have understood:

  • that they were making a will and what effect it would have,
  • the nature and extent of their property, and
  • the people who might reasonably expect to benefit, so they could weigh those claims

The will-maker must also have been free of any disorder of the mind that distorted those judgments. Capacity is assessed at the time the will was signed. A diagnosis of dementia does not automatically mean the will is invalid, because a person can have capacity on one day and lack it on another.

Capacity disputes turn on evidence. Medical records, the treating doctor’s observations, and the file notes of the solicitor who prepared the will are usually central.

Go to top

Undue influence

Yes, but the bar is high. The State Library of NSW’s guide to contesting a will explains the distinction well. Flattery and persuasion by someone who stands to gain from a will are not necessarily unlawful. The Court will only overturn a will where the will-maker was coerced to the point that the will did not reflect their real intentions.

The person alleging undue influence must prove it with full details and supporting evidence. That is difficult, because pressure is rarely applied in front of witnesses. The Court is more alert to the risk where the person who arranged or drafted the will also benefits considerably from it.

Go to top

Lack of knowledge and approval

Yes. Even a will-maker with full capacity must have known and approved of what the will said. This ground often arises where the will-maker

  • was frail,
  • could not read the document,
  • spoke limited English, or
  • relied on someone else to prepare it.

Suspicion increases where the person who prepared or arranged the will receives a substantial benefit under it. In that situation, that person may have to prove to the Court that the will-maker understood and agreed with the will’s terms. Evidence of how the instructions were given, who was present, and whether the will was read over to the will-maker is usually decisive.

Go to top

Forgery and fraud

Yes. A forged will is not a valid will, and the Supreme Court lists forgery and fraud among the grounds for challenge. Forgery claims involve a signature that does not match the will-maker’s, or a will that surfaces in unusual circumstances after the death.

These claims need strong evidence including

  • expert handwriting analysis,
  • evidence from the attesting witnesses, and
  • any record of the will-maker’s intentions.

Fraud can also involve deceiving the will-maker about a fact that led them to change their will.

Go to top

Improper execution

You can, but the challenge is weaker than many people expect. Section 6 of the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) sets the formal requirements for a valid will.

  1. The will must be in writing.
  2. It must be signed by the will-maker in front of two witnesses present at the same time.
  3. The witnesses must also sign.

A will that does not meet those requirements is not automatically invalid. Under Section 8 of the Succession Act 2006, the Court can admit a document as a will if it is satisfied the deceased intended it to operate as their will.

Witnessing raises a separate issue. Under Section 10 of the Succession Act 2006, a gift to a beneficiary who witnessed the will can be void unless certain conditions are met. A challenge on execution grounds therefore needs careful analysis of both the formalities and the evidence of the deceased’s intentions.

Go to top

Revocation by a later will

Yes. A later valid will usually revokes an earlier one, either expressly or to the extent the two are inconsistent. Section 11 of the Succession Act 2006 sets out how a will can be revoked, including by a later will or by the will-maker intentionally destroying it.

Revocation can also happen by operation of law. Marriage generally revokes an earlier will unless it was made in contemplation of that marriage, under Section 12 of the Succession Act 2006. Divorce revokes gifts to a former spouse and their appointment as executor, under Section 13.

Disputes arise where a later will is informal, missing, or itself challenged. The Supreme Court notes that if the original will was last held by the deceased and cannot be found, the law presumes they destroyed it to revoke it. Anyone relying on a copy must produce evidence to rebut that presumption.

Go to top

Being left out

Not as a challenge to validity. The Supreme Court is clear that a will cannot be set aside simply because someone claims the will-maker failed to make adequate provision for them. Being left out, or receiving less than you expected, is not a ground for declaring a will invalid.

The law offers a different remedy. If you are an eligible person and the will does not make adequate provision for you, you can apply for a family provision order under Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006. Eligible persons are listed in Section 57 of that Act and include:

  • A spouse or de facto partner of the deceased
  • A child of the deceased, including an adopted child
  • A former spouse
  • A person who was dependent on the deceased and lived in their household
  • A grandchild who was dependent on the deceased
  • A person living in a close personal relationship with the deceased

The claim must be made within 12 months of the date of death, under Section 58(2), unless the Court extends the time. Legal Aid NSW also publishes guidance on family provision claims.

Go to top

Family provision vs validity

Challenging validity Family provision claim
What you argue The will is not valid The will is valid but inadequate
Who can bring it A person with a legitimate interest, such as an executor or beneficiary under a different will An eligible person under Section 57 of the Succession Act 2006
Time limit Ideally before probate is granted Within 12 months of death
Outcome if successful The will is not admitted to probate The Court orders provision from the estate
Usual costs position Unsuccessful party often pays Costs often paid from the estate under Section 99

The Supreme Court notes that family provision claimants are not interested persons in probate proceedings, because their claim does not depend on which will is admitted. Both types of claim are managed in the Probate and Family Provision List under Practice Note SC Eq 7. Our guide on how much it costs to contest a will in NSW explains how costs are treated in each.

Go to top

Evidence needed

The evidence depends on the ground, but most validity challenges draw on:

  • Medical records and expert medical opinion for capacity claims
  • The solicitor’s file and notes of the will-maker’s instructions
  • Affidavits from the attesting witnesses about how the will was signed
  • Handwriting evidence for forgery claims
  • Earlier wills, letters, and statements showing the will-maker’s intentions
  • Evidence of who arranged the will and who was present

You are entitled to see the will before probate is granted. Section 54 of the Succession Act 2006 lists the people who can inspect and copy it, including beneficiaries under the will or an earlier will, and anyone who would inherit on intestacy.

To stop a grant while you gather evidence, you can file a caveat. It lasts six months under Part 78 Division 69 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970. If the dispute cannot be resolved, it proceeds as a claim for probate in solemn form under Part 78 Rule 72, which a judge decides.

Go to top

Choose the right claim

Most people who come to me unhappy with a will do not have grounds to have it declared invalid. Many do have a strong family provision claim, and the 12-month deadline means that choice needs to be made quickly.

Buckley Lawyers assesses your position, tells you plainly which claim is open to you, and gives you a realistic view of the likely outcome and cost. Most disputes resolve through negotiation or mediation, and we pursue that path first. Read more about what a contested estate is and when a will can be challenged, or visit our contested estates page.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Go to top

Articles
Have a problem?
Call 02 9220 1737 or
Fill the form
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader