Binding Financial Agreement vs Consent Orders

consent orders

A binding financial agreement is a private contract that can be made before, during, or after a relationship, and requires independent legal advice for both parties. Consent orders are Court-approved orders made after separation. They are generally cheaper and harder to challenge. Both can divide property, superannuation, and spousal maintenance.

On this page

Introduction

When a couple agrees on how to divide their property, the next question is how to make that agreement stick. In Australia, there are two formal options under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth): a binding financial agreement or consent orders. Both can finalise a property settlement, but they work differently, cost differently, and suit different situations.

This guide compares a binding financial agreement vs consent orders on timing, legal advice, enforcement, flexibility, and what each can cover. If you have not yet agreed on how to divide your property, our property settlements page explains your options.

Go to top

Key differences

The core difference is who approves the arrangement. A binding financial agreement is a private contract between the parties. Consent orders are orders made by the Court, on terms the parties have agreed.

The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia describes both as ways to document a property agreement under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth):

Binding Financial Agreement Consent Orders
What it is A contract between the parties Orders of the Court made by agreement
Legal basis Part VIIIA (married) or Division 4 of Part VIIIAB (de facto) Section 79 (married) or Section 90SM (de facto)
When it can be made Before, during, or after the relationship After separation
Independent legal advice Mandatory for both parties Recommended, but not required
Court review None The Court must approve the terms
Filed with the Court No Yes
Relative cost Generally higher Generally lower

Legal Aid NSW notes that making a binding financial agreement is generally more expensive than applying for court orders. Our guide on how much a binding financial agreement costs explains why.

Go to top

Before separation

Only a binding financial agreement can be made before separation. A married couple can make one before the marriage under Section 90B, during the marriage under Section 90C, or after divorce under Section 90D of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). De facto couples have the equivalent provisions in Sections 90UB, 90UC, and 90UD.

Consent orders are made in property proceedings between separated parties. They formalise the division of property once the relationship has ended. A couple planning ahead, whether to protect an inheritance, a business, or assets for children from an earlier relationship, will need a BFA.

Go to top

Consent orders without court

Yes. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia confirms that you and your former partner can apply for consent orders without attending court. You file an Application for Consent Orders together, attaching the proposed orders you have agreed on.

The application requires each party to make full disclosure of their financial circumstances and sign a statement confirming that the disclosure is true and correct. A Registrar then reviews the application. Before making property orders, the Court must be satisfied that the orders are just and equitable, as required by Section 79 or Section 90SM of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

That review is one of the main differences between the two options. With consent orders, the Court acts as a safeguard. With a BFA, the safeguard is the independent legal advice each party receives.

Go to top

No. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia states that you are not required to have a lawyer or legal advice before entering into consent orders, although it recommends advice because family law is complex.

A BFA is different. Each party must receive independent legal advice from an Australian legal practitioner before signing. Under Section 90G of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) for married couples, and Section 90UJ for de facto couples, the advice must cover the effect of the agreement on the party’s rights and its advantages and disadvantages. Each lawyer must also sign a statement confirming the advice was given. Without it, the agreement is not binding.

I recommend legal advice for consent orders too, particularly where there are significant assets, trusts, or superannuation. A Registrar’s approval confirms the orders are just and equitable. It does not guarantee they are the best outcome available to you.

Go to top

Enforcement

Consent orders are orders of the Court. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia explains that each party must follow them. Breaching them can have serious consequences, including being found in contempt of court in extreme cases. If a party does not comply, the other can apply to the Court to enforce the orders.

A BFA is enforced as a contract. Legal Aid NSW confirms that a valid binding financial agreement is legally enforceable. The Court’s power to deal with the validity, enforceability, and effect of a financial agreement is found in Section 90KA of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) for married couples, and Section 90UN for de facto couples. Unlike consent orders, which the Court has already approved, a BFA can face an argument about whether it is valid at all before enforcement is considered.

Go to top

Changing them after separation

Both are designed to be final, and both can be changed only in limited circumstances.

Once final property orders are made, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia notes they can be changed only in the circumstances set out in Section 79A (married) or Section 90SN (de facto) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). Those grounds include a miscarriage of justice, such as fraud or the suppression of evidence.

Go to top

Binding financial agreements

Legal Aid NSW explains that the parties can change or end a BFA by making a new agreement with a termination clause, making a termination agreement, or abandoning the agreement. Otherwise, the Court can set aside an agreement only on the grounds in Section 90K (married) or Section 90UM (de facto). Those grounds include

  • fraud, such as hiding important financial information,
  • unconscionable conduct, and
  • a material change in circumstances relating to a child that would cause hardship.

A BFA can therefore be varied by agreement more easily than consent orders can. That flexibility cuts both ways, because a BFA also has more grounds on which a party can later attack it.

Go to top

Property and assets

Both can divide the full range of property: real estate, bank accounts, shares, business interests, vehicles, and debts. Both can also deal with superannuation.

The differences lie in process:

Superannuation

Consent orders that split superannuation require the agreement of every person who must act under them. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia confirms this includes the fund trustee. A BFA can also deal with superannuation under Part VIIIB of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), subject to its own requirements.

Go to top

Transfer duty and tax

Legal Aid NSW notes that property transferred under a binding financial agreement may qualify for a transfer duty exemption and capital gains tax rollover relief. The documents need to be drafted correctly to access those concessions.

Go to top

Future property

Only a BFA made before or during a relationship can deal with property the parties do not yet own, such as a future inheritance.

Go to top

Spousal maintenance

Both can. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia notes that a financial agreement can deal with some or all financial issues, including spousal or de facto maintenance. Legal Aid NSW confirms a BFA can deal with property and maintenance together, or with maintenance alone.

Consent orders can also include spousal maintenance. The Court’s power to order maintenance for a spouse is in Section 74 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), and for a de facto partner in Section 90SE.

Go to top

Consent orders after separation

Yes, and for many separated couples, consent orders are the better choice. They are generally less expensive, the Court reviews the terms, and they are harder to challenge later.

A BFA may still suit some separated couples:

  • where they want their arrangements to remain private and not filed with the Court,
  • where the arrangement is one a Registrar may question, but both parties understand and accept it after independent advice, or
  • where the agreement also needs to deal with matters beyond the division of existing property.

Timing matters for consent orders. Under Section 44(3) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), married couples generally have 12 months after a divorce order takes effect to apply for property orders. Under Section 44(5), de facto couples generally have two years from separation. After those periods, the Court’s permission is needed. If you are approaching a deadline, our divorce and property settlement lawyers can advise on your options.

Go to top

When both cover the same property

They should not. A binding financial agreement prevents the Court from making orders about the matters it covers. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia explains that a binding agreement ousts the Court’s jurisdiction in relation to financial or property proceedings, either generally or on specific issues. For married couples, Section 71A of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) provides that the Court’s property powers do not apply to matters covered by a binding financial agreement.

That means:

  • If a valid BFA covers the property, the Court cannot make consent orders dividing it.
  • If the BFA is invalid or set aside under Section 90K or 90UM, the Court can make property orders instead.
  • A BFA cannot deal with matters already covered by an earlier agreement that is still in force, as Legal Aid NSW notes.

Go to top

Choose the right document

A binding financial agreement suits couples planning ahead, or separated couples who value privacy and are prepared to pay for independent advice on both sides. Consent orders suit most separated couples who have agreed on terms and want Court approval and lower costs. The wrong choice can leave you with a document that fails when it is tested.

Buckley Lawyers advises on both. We tell you plainly which option fits your circumstances, prepare documents built to withstand scrutiny, and negotiate or mediate where terms are not yet agreed. Visit our financial agreements and consent orders pages to learn more.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Go to top

Articles
Have a problem?
Call 02 9220 1737 or
Fill the form
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader