What Are Your Chances of Successfully Contesting a Will?

wills

There is no official success rate for contesting a will in NSW. Outcomes depend on standing, the ground relied on, and above all the evidence, especially medical records and the will-drafter’s file. Suspicious circumstances invite closer scrutiny but do not invalidate a will alone. Many disputes are best resolved through settlement.

On this page

Introduction

What are the chances of contesting a will and winning? It is the right first question, but nobody can answer it honestly without looking at the evidence. There is no official success rate for contesting a will in NSW, and a percentage drawn from other people’s cases tells you very little about yours.

What I can explain is how the Supreme Court decides these disputes, and which factors tend to make a challenge succeed or fail. This guide focuses on challenges to a will’s validity. If your concern is that you were left out or given too little, that is a family provision claim, which has different rules. Our guide on the grounds to contest a will in NSW explains the difference.

Go to top

Factors that decide the outcome

People ask how successful will challenges are as if the answer were fixed. The outcome of any challenge turns on a handful of factors:

  • Standing. You must have a legitimate interest in which will is admitted to probate, such as being a beneficiary under an earlier will.
  • The ground relied on. The Supreme Court recognises specific grounds, including lack of capacity, lack of knowledge and approval, undue influence, forgery, improper execution, and revocation.
  • The quality of the evidence. Most challenges are won or lost on medical records, the will-drafter’s file, and witness accounts.
  • Timing. The Supreme Court prefers challenges to be made before probate is granted and before the estate is dealt with.
  • What you gain if you succeed. If the will falls, the estate passes under an earlier will or the intestacy rules, which may or may not benefit you.

The Supreme Court’s contested proceedings page sets out the recognised grounds and the process.

Go to top

Evidence that helps

The strongest challenges are built on documents created at the time the will was made, not on recollections years later. Useful evidence includes:

  • Medical records and clinical notes from around the date of the will
  • The solicitor’s file, including notes of who gave instructions and who was present
  • Earlier wills and any letters or statements about the will-maker’s intentions
  • Affidavits from the attesting witnesses about how the will was signed
  • Evidence of the relationship between the will-maker and the main beneficiary
  • Expert opinion, such as a medical assessment of capacity or a handwriting analysis

You are entitled to see the will before probate is granted if you fall within Section 54 of the Succession Act 2006. That includes beneficiaries under the will or an earlier will, and anyone who would inherit on intestacy.

Go to top

Testamentary capacity

Capacity is one of the most common grounds in validity disputes. The test applied in NSW comes from Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549. The will-maker must have understood

  • what a will is and its effect,
  • the nature and extent of their property, and
  • the people who might reasonably expect to benefit.

Their judgment must also have been free of any disorder of the mind that distorted those decisions.

Capacity is assessed at the moment the will was signed. A diagnosis of dementia or another condition does not settle the question on its own, because capacity can fluctuate. What matters is the evidence of the will-maker’s state of mind on that day.

A challenge based on capacity is stronger where the medical records show significant cognitive decline close to the date of the will. It is weaker where an experienced solicitor took detailed instructions, recorded the will-maker’s reasons, and found no cause for concern.

Go to top

Undue influence

Undue influence is one of the hardest grounds to prove. The State Library of NSW’s guide to contesting a will explains that flattery and persuasion by someone who stands to gain are not necessarily unlawful. The Court will only overturn a will where the will-maker was coerced to the point that the will did not reflect their real intentions.

The person alleging undue influence must prove it with full details and supporting evidence. That is difficult, because coercion rarely happens in front of witnesses. In my experience, many unsuccessful cases of contesting a will in NSW involve an allegation of undue influence that rested on suspicion alone.

This is also where a family provision claim is often the better option. A child who was cut out after a new partner arrived may struggle to prove coercion, but may have a strong claim that the will failed to make adequate provision for them.

Go to top

Earlier wills

Earlier wills matter in two ways. First, they decide what happens if the challenge succeeds. If the later will is found invalid, the Court may admit the previous valid will instead. If there is no earlier valid will, the estate passes under the intestacy rules in Chapter 4 of the Succession Act 2006.

That means a successful challenge only helps you if you do better under the earlier will or intestacy. It is worth working that out before spending anything on the dispute.

Second, earlier wills can be evidence. A long pattern of consistent wills, followed by a sudden change made in unusual circumstances, can support a challenge. A series of wills showing a gradual shift in the will-maker’s thinking can undermine one. Under Section 11 of the Succession Act 2006, a later will or the intentional destruction of a will can also revoke an earlier one.

Go to top

Witnesses and medical records

Witnesses and medical records are often the most important evidence in the case. Section 6 of the Succession Act 2006 requires a formal will to be signed by the will-maker in the presence of two witnesses present at the same time. Those witnesses can give evidence about how the will was signed and how the will-maker appeared.

The Supreme Court’s rules require affidavit evidence from an attesting witness where there is doubt about the execution of a will. That can arise from unexplained alterations, missing attachments, or tears in the document. These requirements are set out in Part 78 Division 3 Subdivision 3 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970. Medical records carry weight because they are created independently, at the time, by people with no stake in the estate.

Go to top

Suspicious circumstances

Suspicious circumstances are not a separate ground for having a will declared invalid. They can, however, change how the Court approaches the evidence.

An example is where the person who arranged or prepared the will also receives a substantial benefit under it. The State Library of NSW notes that in this situation, that person may have to prove there was no trickery, pressure, force, or fear involved. The Court may require evidence that the will-maker knew and approved of the will’s contents before it will admit the will to probate.

Other circumstances that can raise concern include

  • a will made shortly before death,
  • a dramatic departure from earlier wills, or
  • a will-maker who was isolated from family.

Each can prompt closer scrutiny, but none proves invalidity on its own. The challenge still needs to be framed around a recognised ground, such as lack of knowledge and approval.

Go to top

How the Court decides

A contested probate dispute is decided by a judge. If the dispute cannot be resolved, it proceeds as a claim for probate in solemn form under Part 78 Rule 72 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970, commenced by statement of claim. Notice must be served on everyone who would be adversely affected by the grant, under Part 78 Rules 57 and 64.

The Court decides the case on the balance of probabilities, the civil standard under Section 140 of the Evidence Act 1995. The person asking the Court to admit the will generally bears the burden of establishing that it is valid. Where the will appears regular and was properly signed, the Court will usually infer capacity and knowledge and approval unless the evidence raises a genuine doubt.

If the formal requirements were not met, the Court can still admit the document under Section 8 of the Succession Act 2006 if it is satisfied the deceased intended it to be their will. A technical defect in signing is therefore rarely enough to win a challenge on its own.

Go to top

Why challenges fail

In my experience, will challenges fail for predictable reasons:

  • The wrong claim. The Supreme Court is clear that a will cannot be set aside because someone received less than they expected. That concern belongs in a family provision claim.
  • No standing. The Court notes that family provision claimants and creditors are not interested persons in probate proceedings.
  • Suspicion without evidence. Undue influence and capacity claims need contemporaneous proof.
  • No real benefit. Some challengers would receive nothing more under the earlier will or intestacy.
  • Delay. Challenges brought after the estate has been administered face greater practical obstacles.
  • Technical defects that Section 8 cures. An informal will can still be admitted if the deceased intended it to operate.

A failed challenge is expensive. The Supreme Court warns that unsuccessful applicants may be required to pay the costs of the successful party. Our guide on how much it costs to contest a will in NSW explains that risk in detail.

Go to top

Settlement vs court

So, is it worth contesting a will? The answer depends on the strength of the evidence, what you stand to gain, and what the dispute will cost. For many people, the best outcome is a negotiated settlement.

Court proceedings make sense where the evidence is strong, the other side will not negotiate, or the stakes justify the risk. Otherwise, settlement offers certainty, privacy, and lower costs. It also allows outcomes tailored to the family, such as one beneficiary buying out the others’ share of the family home. The Court can refer proceedings to mediation under Section 26 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005. For family provision claims, Section 98 of the Succession Act 2006 requires mediation before a hearing.

Go to top

Conclusion

Buckley Lawyers gives you a straight assessment of your evidence, what you would gain, and what it will cost, before you commit. We pursue resolution first through negotiation and mediation, and we are ready to run the case if that fails. Read more about what a contested estate is and when a will can be challenged, or visit our contested estates page.

Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Go to top

Articles
Have a problem?
Call 02 9220 1737 or
Fill the form
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader
Google Rating
4.8
Based on 137 reviews
×
js_loader